The OHS Pipe Organ Database

St. Paul Methodist Church
123 South Yellow Springs Street
Springfield, Ohio 45506

OHS Database ID 60137.

See the address on Google Maps.

Status and Condition

This organ is no longer whole; parts were dispersed, and some may have been re-used in a different installation.
We received the most recent update on this organ's state and condition June 29, 2017.

Technical Details

Mechanical key action. Mechanical stop action.

The organ is in a case at the front of the room.


  • This entry describes an original installation of a new pipe organ.
    Identified by J. A. Hefner, listing conversations with this person as the source of the information: Aaron M. Tellers (Tellers Organ Co.).
    According to Aaron M. Tellers, three Felgemaker organs shipped to Springfield, Ohio in 1881 - opus 429, 430, 433. Spec sheets do not exist, but they were apparently similar.
    Opus 429 was installed in St. Paul Methodist Church, although I know nothing of what happened to it. The church closed in the early 2000s, the building was abandoned for a time, then it recently started being restored. ABF Opus 430 went to Christ Episcopal, and Opus 433 went to High Str. Methodist.

    Considering ABF Opus 430 was removed to Trinity Episcopal (London, OH) in 1918, then Opus 433 was broken up and recycled in 1942, I don't know if Opus 429 survived. (Database Manager. May 5, 2017)
  • Updated by J. A. Hefner, who gave this as the source of the information: Personal visit to St. Paul Church and discussion with owner Dave Garrett.
    Built in 1880, St. Paul Methodist was purchased ca. 2002 by local jeweler Dave Garrett, and throughout the restoration process, he has been holding church services in it as well. The Westcott House Foundation also hosts tours. The county library also has a book written on the church, and I will forward that information when I get it.
    According to Garrett, the ABF Opus 429 was there in the 1970s, and it produced a massive sound in the sanctuary hall (seating capacity approx 1500).
    By the 1990s, however, the church had fallen on hard times, and the organ was gutted, and the console/innards sold.
    The façade was retained (as minimally as possible), and ca. 1998, the pipes were painted yellow.
    To retain some organ music, the church added an Allen electronic organ, placing the speakers behind the façade pipes.

    The Garretts have expressed interest in purchasing a pipe organ, and they might wind up using ABF Opus 522 (Heavenly Rest Episcopal/My Church Ohio) as a basis. (Steven E. Lawson. May 29, 2017)
  • Updated by J. A. Hefner, naming this as the source of information: "A History of the St. Paul United Methodist Church, 1880-1980: a Century of Ministry" by the Rev. George R. Copus, 1980.
    The organ initially had a water motor. According to the centennial history by the Rev. George R. Copus, the organ was sent back to Felgemaker at some point en route to Springfield, as it hadn't been tuned. At the same time, the solid walnut pews burned in their Richmond, Indiana, factory, thus the cane seat chairs and six-piece Sunday School orchestra substituted for seating and music. After being factory-tuned, ABF Opus 429 was installed and first used 11 Sept 1881, with the pews arriving later [they were dedicated 7 May 1882]. No mention of electrification is made, though several renovations occurred. In 1964, Rev. Charles Rader [28th pastor] became pastor. At the start of his tenure, the Felgemaker organ was "retired" and replaced with the Allen electronic, which was installed in July 1964. (Steven E. Lawson. May 31, 2017)
  • Updated by J. A. Hefner, listing conversations with this person as the source of the information: Aaron M. Tellers. (Steven E. Lawson. June 29, 2017)

Online Documents

Currently we have no online documents associated with this organ entry. If you can provide us with digital files of contracts, correspondence, dedication programs, or any similar items, please follow this link to our document upload form to send them to us.

If you would like more information about documents included in the Database, please see our Documents Information page.

Other Websites

The database contains no links to external websites that describe this organ. If you know of any sites that contain information about it, please use the Update form to send us the URL.


Click on a thumbnail to see the larger image in a new tab.

Organ Case and Façade Pipes. Photograph by J. A. Hefner 2017-05-28
Church Exterior. Photograph by J. A. Hefner 2017-05-28
Former Console Location. Photograph by J. A. Hefner 2017-05-28
Carving Detail above former Console location. Photograph by J. A. Hefner 2017-05-28
Church Exterior. Photograph by J. A. Hefner 2017-05-28
Vintage postcard, showing the church as Franklin H. Penfield designed it. Vintage postcard, date unknown, courtesy of J. A. Hefner

If you can provide us with additional photographs, you may upload them through our online form. For further information please see our expectations for adding photographs.



We would very much like to have a stoplist of this organ to display on this page. If you have the information to provide one, please use one of these links to send it to us: