Wm. Johnson & Son
Opus 757, 1891

The structure, therefore, with furnishings cost about $55,000.

Included in that sum was the fund raised by the members of the choir and others for a pipe organ...When the new building was nearing completion, the fund amounted to about $800 and was paid over to Johnson Bros, of Westfield, Mass., on the $2,500 purchase price of the organ.
-- History of the First Baptist Church of Jamestown, New York : 1827-1915 : organized as a branch church December 25th 1827 : organized as an independent body May 24th, 1832 [text compiled by the Internet Archive]

The book apparently had a photo fo the organ printed on page 69.

The church was seriously damaged by fire in 1914. The Johnson was presumed destroyed, but may have survived in some capacity and been renovated by an unknown builder. In 1938 the Kilgen company installed a new organ, which was rebuilt and enlarged as a three-manual by the Tellers company in 1965. Circa 1974-75, the church was utterly destroyed by an arson fire leaving only parts of two walls. The church exists in a new and much smaller building, and is not believed to contain a real organ.

An original installation. Identified by John Igoe, using information found in Johnson Organs, 1844-1898: Wm. A Johnson, Johnson Organ Co., Johnson & Son: a documentary issued in honor the two hundredth anniversary of his birth, 1816-2016 / by Scot L. Huntington, Len Levasseur, Barbara Owen, Stephen L. Pinel, and Martin R. Walsh. Cranbury, New Jersey: The Princeton Academy of the Arts, Culture, and Society, 2015..
--